Why Paneer Doesn’t Taste Like It Used To - Because It Isn’t Paneer Anymore

With paneer being a staple in Indian households—from school lunchboxes to festive dinners—its rising demand has unfortunately also given rise to an unsettling trend: fake or adulterated paneer being sold in local markets. From starch-laced blocks to chemically processed imitations, not all paneer is what it claims to be. So how do you ensure what you’re eating is pure, safe, and genuinely dairy? Here are seven easy yet effective ways to identify fake paneer right at home:


Authentic paneer has a mild, milky aroma and feels soft, slightly grainy, and crumbly to the touch. If the block smells sour, chemical-like, or oddly oily, it’s a red flag. A rubbery or overly smooth texture also indicates that the product may not be pure milk-based.

• Drop a cube of paneer into a glass of cold or warm water.
• Real paneer typically floats or retains shape.
• Fake paneer often sinks, may turn slimy, or even dissolve, especially if made with starch or other binders.

When lightly fried or heated, real paneer should:

• Brown slightly
• Hold its shape
• Release little to no water

In contrast, fake paneer may melt unevenly, break apart, or release excess oil, indicating synthetic additives or improper processing.


This simple home test helps catch starch adulteration:

• Boil the paneer and let it cool.
• Add a few drops of iodine solution (available at medical stores).
• If it turns blue or black, starch is present—definitely a cause for concern

Note: Some paneer may be coated in flour during cooking—so ensure you’re testing a clean, raw sample.


This lesser-known trick is surprisingly effective:

• Place the paneer in water and sprinkle some toor dal powder or soya flour.
• Wait 10 minutes.
• If the water turns red or pink, this could indicate the presence of detergents or urea, both harmful and illegal.

Real paneer has a clean, fresh, slightly sweet taste. If your paneer tastes bitter, soapy, or unnaturally greasy, it’s better to discard it. When buyingpackaged paneer:

• Look for FSSAI certification
• Avoid labels that mention "imitation" or "analogue cheese"
• Stick to trusted brands or local dairies

If buying from loose counters, ask when the paneer was made and request a small sample if possible.

Several recent raids across India have exposed large quantities of fake paneer made from starch, synthetic milk, and even washing detergents. Consuming such products may pose serious health risks—from digestive issues to long-term damage to kidneys and liver.

Homemade paneer takes under an hour and requires just two ingredients: milk and lemon juice (or vinegar). Boil, curdle, strain, press—and you’ll have fresh, safe paneer without any additives.