The Udasis: What Nanak Was Looking For in Twenty Years of Walking
Guru Nanak left Sultanpur Lodhi in 1499 or 1500, the historians disagree on the exact year, but they agree on what he said when he came back from the river where he had disappeared for three days. He said: there is no Hindu, there is no Mussalman. Then he walked out of his house and did not stop walking for two decades.
The journeys have a name in Sikh tradition: the Udasis, from the Sanskrit word for one who has gone beyond, one who has set aside attachment. There were four of them, and together they covered terrain that no single traveller of that century could be said to have covered on foot: east to Assam and Bengal, south to Sri Lanka, north into Tibet and the Himalayas, west and northwest into Mecca, Baghdad, and possibly further. The distances in the Janam Sakhis, the devotional biographies written by those who came after, are sometimes miraculous, sometimes contradictory. What they agree on is the direction of his attention. He walked toward argument. He walked toward the places where the question of God was most fiercely contested.
The Question He Was Carrying
What Nanak was looking for is best understood through what he rejected at the start. He had worked as a Modi, a storekeeper, in the service of Daulat Khan Lodi at Sultanpur. He had a wife, two sons, a position. The morning he went to the river and came back changed, he resigned the position and gave away what he had. He was not renouncing the world in the Hindu ascetic sense, he never shaved his head, never joined an order, never asked his family to follow him into poverty. He was refusing the idea that the sacred and the ordinary occupied different territories.
The Bhagavad Gita, in Chapter 6, Verse 1, speaks of the one who performs their duty without dependence on the fruit of action as the true renunciant, not the one who lights no fire and performs no rites. Nanak seems to have taken this not as a spiritual instruction but as a description of what he already was. The Udasis were not a withdrawal. They were an investigation conducted in motion.
What He Found in the South
The first Udasi went east and south, and the stories the Janam Sakhis tell about it are stories of encounter: with Brahmin pandits who debated him on the banks of the Godavari, with fishermen in the coastal towns, with the priests at Rameswaram who performed rituals facing the sea. At Rameswaram, the story goes, Nanak watched the priests throw water toward the sun as an offering to their ancestors. He turned and began throwing water in the opposite direction, toward the west, toward his fields in Punjab. When they asked him what he was doing, he said: if your water can reach the sun, mine can reach my fields. If it cannot reach my fields, yours cannot reach the sun.
The point was not mockery. It was the same point he had been making since Sultanpur: that form without understanding is not devotion, it is habit. He was not anti-ritual. He was anti-unconsciousness. The sabads he composed on the first Udasi, later gathered into the Guru Granth Sahib, are not polemics. They are meditations on the same sky seen from different temples.
What He Found in the West
The third Udasi is the one that most challenges the imagination. Nanak walked to Mecca. He arrived, according to the Janam Sakhis, and lay down to sleep with his feet pointing toward the Kaaba. A qazi woke him angrily and told him not to point his feet toward the house of God. Nanak said: then turn my feet in the direction where God is not. The qazi, the story says, could not find that direction.
He went on to Medina, to Baghdad, where a stone in the city's Baoli Sahib Gurdwara still bears an inscription said to date from his visit. Whether the inscription is contemporary or later is a question for archaeologists. What is not in question is that Nanak composed in Persian and Arabic as well as Punjabi and Braj Bhasha, that his sabads engage Islamic theology on its own terms, that the structure of his understanding of the Divine, formless, beyond attribute, beyond name, the Ik Onkar of the Mul Mantar, has a relationship to the Sufi concept of the Haqq that is not accidental.
What He Was Not Looking For
He was not looking for synthesis. The temptation, looking back, is to read the Udasis as the construction project of a man who wanted to combine Hinduism and Islam into something new. That reading flattens what he actually did. He did not take the best of two traditions and subtract the difficult parts. He interrogated both, refused the parts that seemed to him to confuse the ritual for the reality, and composed something that was neither and both.
The Mul Mantar, which opens the Guru Granth Sahib, does not describe a God who belongs to a tradition. It describes a being who is one, whose name is truth, who is the creator, without fear, without enmity, beyond time, not born, self-illumined. The description is not a compromise between two theologies. It is a statement that the question both theologies were answering had been slightly wrong from the beginning.
What He Came Back With
Nanak settled at Kartarpur in 1521 or 1522, on land given by a local chieftain, and spent the last years of his life farming. He farmed. He sang. He fed people. The langar, the free communal kitchen, that became one of the defining institutions of Sikhism began at Kartarpur as a simple daily practice: everyone eats together, regardless of caste, regardless of faith. It was not a symbol. It was the argument made physical.
He died in 1539. The story told in the Janam Sakhis is that his Hindu followers wanted to cremate him and his Muslim followers wanted to bury him, and that when they lifted the sheet from his body, there was only a heap of flowers. Both communities took half and did what they wished. Whether this happened is not the point. The point is that the people who knew him could not agree on what he was, and that he would have considered that exactly right.