Watched Everything on Netflix? Think Again—These Gems Are Still Hiding
Mandvi Singh | Apr 25, 2025, 17:00 IST
Just when you thought you'd hit the bottom of the Netflix barrel, we’re here to prove there’s more gold to mine. From under-the-radar indie films to criminally underrated series, this article uncovers hidden gems still streaming on Netflix in 2025. Whether you're into thrillers, heartwarming dramas, or clever comedies, these lesser-known titles will have you hooked. Get ready to refresh your watchlist with these must-see picks that somehow slipped through the algorithmic cracks.
Whether you’re a film buff searching for underappreciated art or just tired of the same suggestions, this list is your passport to some truly underrated cinematic experiences. These aren’t just good movies—they're the kind you'll want to recommend to everyone after watching.
chill
Let’s dig in.
1. "The Half of It" (2020)
Why It’s a Gem:
This quiet, heartfelt film is more than just a modern-day Cyrano tale. Directed by Alice Wu, The Half of It explores identity, friendship, and love in a small town. It’s subtle, sweet, and deeply human, with stunning performances that stick with you long after the credits roll.
2. "Calibre" (2018)
Why It’s a Gem:
Set in the Scottish Highlands, this taut thriller follows two friends whose hunting trip takes a dark turn. Calibre is nerve-wracking in the best way—suspenseful, morally complex, and beautifully shot. It's one of those movies that makes your stomach drop while asking, "What would I do in this situation?"
3. "Blue Jay" (2016)
Why It’s a Gem:
Shot entirely in black and white, this deeply emotional film stars Mark Duplass and Sarah Paulson as former high school sweethearts who reconnect in their hometown. The dialogue is raw, the performances are vulnerable, and the chemistry is undeniable. If you love character-driven stories, this one is unmissable.
4. "I Don't Feel at Home in This World Anymore" (2017)
Why It’s a Gem:
A woman fed up with the state of the world teams up with an eccentric neighbor to track down the thieves who burglarized her home. Sounds quirky? It is. But it’s also sharp, surprisingly violent, and weirdly uplifting. Melanie Lynskey and Elijah Wood are unforgettable in this genre-bending indie.
5. "The Platform" (2019)
Why It’s a Gem:
Not for the faint of heart, this Spanish sci-fi thriller is a disturbing yet brilliant allegory of class, power, and survival. Set in a vertical prison where food is rationed from top to bottom, The Platform is visually inventive and psychologically gripping—a true mind-bender.
6. "Paddleton" (2019)
Why It’s a Gem:
This understated dramedy explores friendship and mortality through the lens of two mismatched neighbors, played perfectly by Mark Duplass (again!) and Ray Romano. It’s a slow burn, but it sneaks up on you with genuine emotion and quiet heartbreak.
7. "Shirkers" (2018)
Why It’s a Gem:
An ode to lost dreams and cinematic obsession, Shirkers tells the story of a group of young women in Singapore who made a groundbreaking indie film in the ’90s—only for the footage to vanish. Part mystery, part memoir, this doc is hypnotic and deeply personal.
8. "The Fundamentals of Caring" (2016)
Why It’s a Gem:
This road trip dramedy, starring Paul Rudd and Craig Roberts, balances humor and heartbreak with ease. Based on the novel by Jonathan Evison, it follows a caregiver and his sarcastic teen client on an unexpected adventure. It’s charming, offbeat, and just the right amount of feel-good.
9. "The Dig" (2021)
Why It’s a Gem:
Overlooked despite its star-studded cast (Carey Mulligan, Ralph Fiennes), The Dig is a gentle, meditative film about an archaeological excavation in pre-WWII England. It’s a story of legacy, loss, and discovery—both literal and emotional. Gorgeous cinematography, slow pacing, and quietly moving performances make it a hidden treasure.
10. "His House" (2020)
Why It’s a Gem:
This psychological horror film uses supernatural elements to explore trauma, grief, and the refugee experience. It’s terrifying in moments, but what really lingers is the emotional depth. With powerful performances and social commentary that cuts deep, His House is horror with something to say.
11. "Kodachrome" (2017)
Why It’s a Gem:
This father-son road trip film, led by Ed Harris and Jason Sudeikis, is a touching exploration of reconciliation and legacy. It’s set against the backdrop of the last Kodachrome film lab, making it both a metaphor for memory and a celebration of a lost art form.
12. "Private Life" (2018)
Why It’s a Gem:
Kathryn Hahn and Paul Giamatti play a couple navigating infertility in this brutally honest, often funny portrayal of love and longing. Writer-director Tamara Jenkins delivers a deeply human story that avoids clichés and instead offers something far more meaningful and real.
13. "The Meyerowitz Stories" (2017)
Why It’s a Gem:
A surprisingly rich and poignant family drama featuring Adam Sandler (yes, really), Ben Stiller, and Dustin Hoffman. Directed by Noah Baumbach, this film is an insightful look at sibling rivalry, parental approval, and artistic identity—with razor-sharp writing and standout performances.
14. "Cam" (2018)
Why It’s a Gem:
A bold, eerie, and surprisingly layered film about identity in the digital age. Cam follows a camgirl who discovers her account has been hijacked by a doppelgänger. It’s sleek, smart, and far more complex than it initially appears—one of the most original thrillers Netflix has quietly released.
15. "Tigertail" (2020)
Why It’s a Gem:
This intergenerational immigrant story, written and directed by Master of None co-creator Alan Yang, is tender and beautifully shot. It weaves together past and present in a poetic meditation on memory, family, and the pursuit of happiness. Quiet, emotional, and criminally underrated.
Why You Should Dig Deeper on Netflix
watch and chill
So the next time you find yourself sighing, “There’s nothing to watch,” dig a little deeper. Scroll past the top 10. Explore the indie section. Use search, not just suggestions. These hidden gems are waiting—and they’re worth discovering.
Explore the latest trends and tips in Health & Fitness, Travel, Life Hacks, Fashion & Beauty, and Relationships at Times Life!
Frequently Asked Question:
What to watch on Netflix hidden gems?
Discover underrated Netflix movies that flew under the radar but are totally worth your time- What is the hidden treasure movie on Netflix?
It's that overlooked masterpiece you'll wish you'd seen sooner—check our curated list to find your next favorite.